Miramistin and Chlorhexidine, what's the difference: a list of cheap analogues

Use of the drug MiramistinMiramistin is a broad spectrum antiseptic medication. It is used in dermatology, surgery, gynecology, dentistry, otolaryngology, traumatology, combustiology (severe burns). It is non-toxic, therefore it can be used by all groups of the population, including pregnant women and children.

The only disadvantage is its relatively high cost, which makes you think about the choice of antiseptic in his favor. In this review, we present a list of similar drugs that are used in otolaryngology, only cheaper.

List of cheap analogues with price

Miramistin itself 0.01% sold at prices ranging from 170 to 250 rudders per bottle of 100 ml. But most often visitors come to the pharmacy and ask for analogues that are not inferior to the drug in action, but only cheaper. This list looks like this:

  • Chlorhexidine 0.05% costs 15 rudders per 100 ml.
  • Hexoral 0.1% will cost 30 rubles for 200 ml.
  • Rotokan costs 32 rubles.
  • Chlorophyllipt on an oil basis of 2% will cost 140 rubles for 20 ml.
  • Furatsilin 0,02% - 70 rubles for 200 ml.
  • Protorgol drops 2% - the price is 90 rubles.
  • Inhalipt in the form of an aerosol - 90 rubles for 30 ml.

These drugs are clearly cheaper than Miramistin. Other analogs stand in the same row for the price or even higher, for example, these include:

  • Drug costDekasan.
  • Octinisept.
  • Dioxidine.
  • Malavit
  • Lizobact.
  • Tantum Verde.

The first list highlighted Chlorhexidine. It is he who occupies a leading position, since Miramistina is cheaper by a factor of ten.

What to buy Miramistin or Chlorhexidine?

These two drugs belong to the same group of antiseptics, but are not analogous in composition. Since according to the instructions for use, they have different active ingredients. Miramistin spectrum of action superior to chlorhexidine. Since he is ruining:

  • Gram-positive and Gram-negative microorganisms,
  • A large number of protozoa,
  • Many fungi.

This gives him the right to apply even in venereal practice.

On the use of Chlorhexidine and Miramistin are similar in many respects, so they are called counterparts. If manufacturers compare them, then everyone “pulls the blanket over himself,” essentially praising his drug. In any case, the drugs act within their capabilities. When the bacterium that caused the inflammatory process, will be in the spectrum of their actions, it will become vulnerable to them.

Tip! Children and pregnant women should use Miramistin.

It should be noted that Chlorhexidine is used mainly for the skin. Since the treatment of mucous membranes may have side effects: darkening of the enamel of the teeth, burning, taste disturbance, dryness and others.

If you use chlorhexidine for throat treatment, then allergic people may experience allergies, so it is better to choose Miramistin, which will relieve from the side effects of Chlorhexidine.

However, if the latter is applied in short courses, then unpleasant moments occur in rare cases. Patients are satisfied with both the result of the drug and its price.

The following drugs can replace Miramistin and Chlorhexidine for throat diseases:

  • Antiangin.
  • Kameton.
  • Gorlospas.
  • Novosept.
  • Lugol.
  • Strepsils and others.

What to choose: Miramistin or Tantum Verde?

Miramistin and Cheap ChlorhexidineCheap drug can not be called because it price over 240 rubles. Tantum Verde is a nonsteroidal medicine of anti-inflammatory action, used only in dentistry and otolaryngology. Miramistin has a wider spectrum of action.

The composition of these drugs are completely different substances. Tantum Verde? except anti-inflammatory effect? It also provides painkillers, Miramistin does not have such properties, as it is used only as an antibacterial drug, although it is not an antibiotic.

Tantum Verde is indicated for the treatment of children from the age of six, Miramistin - from early childhood. Proceeding from this, children under 6 are recommended to use only Miramistin, and according to its analogue, appointed only after 10 years.

If the child is over 6 years old, then each individual case should be considered separately. Therefore, the doctor will answer the question about choosing a remedy better. Often the doctor prescribes, adhering to the rule, if bacterial flora prevails in the nasopharynx - Miramistin, with mixed - Tantum Verde.

Why, in case of sore throat, when there are a lot of bacteria in the throat, the doctor prescribes Tantum Verde and not Miramistin? In angina, a systemic antibiotic is used, for children it is sold in the form of a suspension, it eliminates bacteria. Tantum Verde relieves inflammation locally, that is, in the pharynx and tonsils. Therefore, do not rush to treat your throat yourself, receiving only the advice of a pharmacist.

The side effects of the drugs are almost identical, while applying Tantum Verde there was also some drowsiness.

Miromistin or Lizobakt?

How miramistin is usedLizobact is used only for the treatment of dental and otolaryngological diseases, available in tablets only. Like Miramistin is an antiseptic. The composition of the drugs are not identical, but the action is similar. Tablets are used mainly outside the home, while at home Miramistin becomes preferable.

Lizobakt number 30 is sold at about 120 rubles more expensive. However, it is necessary to compare the fact that a pack of 30 tablets for the treatment of an adult patient will last for 5 days, while rinsing a day consumes approximately 30 ml of Miramistin, which is why the bottle lasts only for 3 days. Hence the conclusion that the price of drugs is about the same.

Contraindications Lizobakta - age up to 3 years and lactose intolerance. Allergic reactions may occur when resorbing Lizobact tablets. Miramistin can cause short-term burning of the mucous membranes of the mouth.

Inhalipt or Miramistin?

The first relates to antimicrobial agents. This is a combined anti-inflammatory drug. It is used only to prevent diseases of the oral cavity and pharynx. The release of the drug is in the form of an aerosol. Inhalipt apply only after 3 years of age, does not apply to women in the position and during lactation.

When using the drug can cause a slight burning sensation and allergies, but most often these unpleasant phenomena do not occur or pass quickly. Active ingredients - peppermint and eucalyptus oil can cause unpleasant side effectsif there is an allergy. Sometimes during treatment with Ingalipt, especially overdose, nausea, vomiting, and pain in the stomach can occur.

Ingalipt's price is significantly lower than Miramistin, therefore, it is the preferred drug. However, the latter has a stronger effect against bacteria, therefore, it is more often used in case of complications arising after past viral infections.

Miramistin or Rotokan?

Drug benefitsThe drug is made on a natural basis and belongs to the antiseptic. The composition of Rotokan includes extracts of chamomile, calendula, yarrow. It acts more gently, except for the anti-inflammatory effect, is able to regenerate mucous membranes, stop minor bleeding, relieve spasm and discomfort in the mouth. However, the antiseptic properties of Miramistin higher.

The instructions for the drug Rotokan says that it is used mainly for the treatment of dental diseases, as well as in the pathology of the gastrointestinal tract (gastroduodenitis, enterocolitis). It is often used to treat tonsillitis, pharyngitis, acute respiratory viral infection and flu, especially if the patient experiences allergies during treatment with non-natural remedies.

Rotokan in very rare cases can cause an allergic reaction. Children are prescribed the drug when they reach 3 years of age. Prepare the drug as follows: in a glass of boiled warm water stir 1 tsp.. Adults dosage can be made more concentrated: 3 spoons per cup of water.

At the beginning of the oropharyngeal disease, use safer drugs, such as Rotocan, Miramistin, leave for more complex cases. The price of Rotokan is about 8 times cheaper than its undeniable advantages.

Analogs of the drug for children

Unfortunately, today in the children's ENT practice there are not very many drugs that would be more affordable in price than Miramistin. As a rule, the same drugs as for adults are cheap analogues for treating ENT organs. Old proven tools are:

  • Chlorophyllipt in oil - 140 rubles.
  • Chlorhexidine 0.05% costs 15 rubles per 100 ml.
  • Hexoral 0.1% at a price of 30 rubles for 200 ml.
  • Ingalipt 30 ml in the form of aerosols - 90 rubles.
  • Lugol in the form of a spray will cost 110 rubles.

Malavit

Also, the natural drug Malavit boasts good results. But it is quite expensive - 200 rubles per bottle of 30 ml. It is used to treat children after 5 years of age.

The positive qualities of the drug is its wide spectrum of action. It can be used for the treatment of the oropharynx, as well as for other pathologies:

  • Hematomas.
  • Dermatitis.
  • Wounds.
  • Burns
  • Chilblains.
  • Neuritis.
  • Insect bites.

Malavit fights viruses, relieves pain, has antibacterial and antifungal effects. It copes well with fungal flora after treatment with chemical antiseptics. The tool is used for both treatment and prevention.

Among the advantages of Malavita is its cost effectiveness. Use only 5-10 drops per 100 ml of waterthat is sufficient to prepare a solution. The finished liquid is used for rinsing the mouth and rinsing the nose. Malavit is applicable to children under 5 years of age. The solution is prepared, guided by the proportion: a drop to the year of life plus 100 ml of water.

Malavit should not be put off just because it is a bit more expensive than Miramistin. The drug is Russian production and it has discounts if you buy in online pharmacies.

Thus, having considered all the positive aspects of Malavita, it can be concluded that its price is no more expensive than Miramistin, since the costs of the drug are low due to its economy. This makes it possible to use it for a long time.

Miramistin or Chlorophyllipt?

Use of the drug MiramistinThese two drugs are similar in severity of action against bacteria. They are able to destroy a wide range of pathogenic microorganisms. Both drugs are widely used in various fields of medicine.

Chlorophyllipt is very popular in children's practice. It is prescribed for infections of ENT organs, dental ailments, and also for the treatment of burns, enterocolitis, gastritis, ulcers, erosions, pleurisy, peritonitis, and other problems.

The advantage of Chlorophyllipta is its natural composition, in which there are leaves of eucalyptus ball. In the instructions for use of the drug there is no clear distinction by age, but if you look at the medical cards, you can very often find its purpose. As a rule, it can be applied already from 3 years old. For kids, a diluted alcohol solution is better, but if there is no allergy, the oil analog will act more gently, the price is lower.

Chlorophyllipt will cost about 40 rubles cheaper than Miramistin.

Each case is unique, so only the doctor at the reception will pick up an antiseptic for your child. Only practice will show what is better - Miramistin or Chlorophyllipt.

So, we have considered the cheapest means of antiseptic series, acting like Miramistin. However, in addition to the price, it is necessary to take into account the composition of the drug, since it is the active substance that allows to judge its identity.

Implantation

Veneers

Crowns